History witchcraft, feminism…lots to discuss in Molly Aitken's novel Bright I Burn.
There’s so much to dissect in Bright I Burn by Molly Aitken. This fabulous and fast moving novel touches on history, witchcraft, feminism, relationships. The characters within are larger than life, making decisions you can’t help but be tempted to judge. We bet you were spellbound from page one! Ready to start diving into conversation or consideration? Kick off with our questions. Remember, though: Spoilers abound! While you read, check out the full Page & Pairing guide to the book.
Bright I Burn
by Molly Aitken
1. Bright I Burn is inspired by the true story of the first woman condemned as a witch in medieval Ireland. Did you have any preconceived perception of witches from previous centuries before reading the novel? What were those ideas? Has your perception changed since reading the novel? How?
2. A lot of Alice’s choices were driven by her love of money and her quest to be financially secure and independent. Do you think this was her primary motivation for her most consequential actions? What else do you believe motivated her?
3. Do you believe that Alice was truly in love with any of her husbands? If so, which one? If there are any you believe she didn’t love, and that the marriage was wholly transactional for her, how do you think she justified this to herself?
4. The nature of Alice’s relationship with Petronilla seems to shift as the novel goes on. What did you learn about Alice through their interactions? Did you feel their friendship was true? Did you believe Petronilla to be a trustworthy friend? Why or why not?
5. The arrival of the bishop of Ossory marks a distinct turn of circumstances for Alice. What do you make of the bishop’s hyperfocus on her? What do you think most strongly drove his intentions? Did you feel his fate was a satisfactory conclusion to his story?
6. By novel’s end, what did you think of the relationship between Alice and her son, Will? Was she a good mother to Will? Was Will a good and loyal son to Alice?
7. What do you think was the primary driver of accusations of witchcraft during this era? Do you believe that witchcraft is still prevalent today?
8. If you could have one more chapter in the novel, on whom would you want it to focus?